Identity Theft - What to do?

[CleanNeon98]

**** like this would only happen to me lol

I'm at the gym today, putt my stuff in my locker and leave it without a lock (never had a problem with this before and I've always had faith in people).

Go to work out, about 2 hours later go back and find my hoody and car keys in place, but wallet missing.

At some point in my routine someone stole my **** and tried to use it. I called the bank and cancelled my debit card right away but some damage was done (not too bad).

At 1:25 the thief tried to withdraw money from an ATM using my card and got my pin wrong
At 1:37 the thief filled up his car at the same gas station

I figure the place has plenty of cameras especially near the ATM (it's a wawa gas station). Filed a police report with the items missing.

Wallet
$90 cash
TD bank card
Wachovia Card
Licence
Reg
Ins
etc.etc.

Called the police department tonight to see if they had gone to the gas station to look at the security tapes around that time to see who was using my card and they basically told me there is nothing they can do and to just go and get new cards and a licence etc. although this should be pretty simple for them to figure out.

The wawa probbably won't let me see the tapes for myself and the trainer at the gym who I work out with says his credit card was stolen about a week ago and he has a suspicion about some guy who wanders in and out of the locker room 6-7 times during his routine, could be the same person, could be different.

What's my next move?

P.S. I contacted Experian and put out a red alert on my name (they transfer the info to Equifax and Transunion also) because I think my SSN was in my wallet somewhere and I don't want anything else happening.