Just for point of reference, the EVO is a very rare color and is either loved or hated by the Miata community.
A very clean, low mileage example just popped up on a local board...with a HT, and unfortunately a automatic...but it's expected to fetch $9-11K.
Link to LVMOC
Let them total it, then make sure they know it's very difficult to replace due to limited edition color...might net you a better payout.